259 Melrose St
Obscure Coffee Roasters is a Puerto Rican-focused specialty coffee shop and nano-roastery on Melrose Street in Bushwick, founded by Norberto Pena, who grew up in Puerto Rico. Before opening his first brick-and-mortar location in mid-2025, Pena spent approximately three years building the brand through bar takeovers and pop-ups across the city, developing a following among specialty coffee enthusiasts who appreciated his commitment to Latin American producers and rare Puerto Rican beans. The cafe occupies a uniquely unconventional space — it sits inside the entrance of the Bushwick Comedy Club, with a door at the back of the shop leading to the forty-seat comedy theater. There is no external signage beyond a sidewalk sandwich board, and the dark-colored interior reflects Pena's passion for heavy metal music, giving the shop a moody, countercultural aesthetic that is entirely distinctive in the Brooklyn coffee landscape. Pena roasts his own beans, renting time on a Loring S15 Falcon roaster owned by fellow Bushwick company Loveless Coffees, and roasting once or twice per week. The coffee roster is exclusively Latin American — featuring beans from Peru, Mexico, Colombia, and other origins — with Puerto Rican coffee as a central focus whenever it is available. Due to the extreme scarcity of Puerto Rican specialty coffee (demand on the island exceeds supply), it is served only as in-house brews and not sold in bags. Pena sources directly from farms and collectives, with a particular focus on small producers experimenting with creative post-harvest processing techniques. Signature drinks reflect the Puerto Rican heritage: the Coquito Latte is built on the traditional holiday drink coquito — mixed dairy and coconut milks with cinnamon, cloves, and vanilla, with espresso replacing rum — while the Tamarindo Spritz draws inspiration from Puerto Rican piraguas, the island's beloved shaved-ice treats. Obscure Coffee Roasters has been featured in Daily Coffee News, the Brooklyn Eagle, The Infatuation, and Coffee Franchise Hub, and sells roasted beans online at obscure.coffee.
Help us keep info accurate — suggest an update.