Polly's Cafe

Polly's Cafe sits on a quiet corner of Classon Avenue between St. Johns and Sterling Places — technically on the Crown Heights border but consistently called Prospect Heights by locals. The cafe runs La Colombe coffee paired with pastries from Balthazar, and has built a strong following on the strength of its location near Prospect Park, the Brooklyn Botanic Garden, and Grand Army Plaza. The coffee program is well-executed across the standard third-wave format. The food side leans light — pastries, sandwiches, breakfast plates — and the space supports both quick visits and longer working sessions. Part of the Evelyn's Daughter Hospitality group, with a sister location on Rogers Avenue. A reliable local pick.