Prospect Heights★ 4.5Verified July 4, 2026
766 Classon Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11238, USA
Closed· opens today at 7am






Customers love Polly's Cafe for its charming atmosphere, great food and drinks, and friendly staff. The cafe is a favorite spot for working, reading, or simply enjoying a meal. Many reviewers appreciate the cozy backyard and welcoming environment.
Synthesized from recent Google reviews
Help us keep info accurate. Suggest an update.
Polly's Cafe sits on a quiet corner of Classon Avenue between St. Johns and Sterling Places, technically on the Crown Heights border but consistently called Prospect Heights by locals. The cafe runs La Colombe coffee paired with pastries from Balthazar, and has built a strong following on the strength of its location near Prospect Park, the Brooklyn Botanic Garden, and Grand Army Plaza. The coffee program is well-executed across the standard third-wave format. The food side leans light: pastries, sandwiches, breakfast plates, and the space supports both quick visits and longer working sessions. Part of the Evelyn's Daughter Hospitality group, with a sister location on Rogers Avenue. A reliable local pick.