Brighton Beach★ 4.6Verified August 3, 2026
Cafeteria Maestro
1033 Brighton Beach Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11235, USA
What to know
At a Glance
Hours
- Sunday
- 7:00 AM to 6:00 PM
- Monday to Friday
- 6:00 AM to 7:00 PM
- Saturday
- 7:00 AM to 6:00 PM
What regulars say
Customers rave about Cafeteria Maestro, praising its delicious desserts, original recipes, and high-quality ingredients. The cafe's owners are also commended for their hospitality and attention to detail. The atmosphere is described as clean, spotless, and having a positive energy.
Synthesized from recent Google reviews
Frequently asked
- Where is Cafeteria Maestro?
- Cafeteria Maestro is at 1033 Brighton Beach Ave in Brighton Beach, Brooklyn.
- How is Cafeteria Maestro rated?
- Cafeteria Maestro has a 4.6-star rating from 270 Google reviews.
- Does Cafeteria Maestro serve specialty coffee?
- Yes, Cafeteria Maestro serves specialty coffee.
Know this spot?
Help us keep info accurate. Suggest an update.
About Cafeteria Maestro
Cafeteria Maestro sits in Brighton Beach, where it has been open for over a year and holds a 4.6 Google rating across 264 reviews. One reviewer who rarely drank coffee before says every drink there is delicious, and the pastry work draws praise, with a meringue roll from the cafe's pastry chef described as light, tender, and not overly sweet. Reviews paint a mixed picture of the experience. One former regular reports rushed coffee, overheated milk in a cappuccino, and pastries that tasted days old, and another visitor describes disrespectful treatment at the counter, while others single out the pastry chef and the quality of the food. The kitchen also makes syrniki, though one reviewer found them cooked outside and raw inside, so opinions on execution vary.