What are the best specialty coffee shops in Sheepshead Bay?

IGAM COFFEE, Lusso Le Caffe, Shepherd's Cup are among the best specialty coffee shops in Sheepshead Bay, each serving specialty-grade beans. Compare ratings and hours above.

How many craft coffee shops are in Sheepshead Bay?

We track 6 craft coffee shops in Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn, each with verified amenities and Google ratings. The full list is above.

6 shopsUpdated October 2026

Specialty Coffee Shops in Sheepshead Bay

These 6 Sheepshead Bay coffee shops treat coffee as a craft: specialty-grade beans, careful brewing, and in many cases on-site roasting, led by IGAM COFFEE.

Part of our Sheepshead Bay coffee guide and our Brooklyn-wide specialty coffee list.

Sheepshead Bay specialty coffee

4.9

IGAM COFFEE

1921 Avenue U, Brooklyn, NY 11229, USA

Craft coffee

4.9

Lusso Le Caffe

2692 Coney Island Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11235, USA

Craft coffee

4.8

Shepherd's Cup

2123 Avenue U, Brooklyn, NY 11229, USA

Excellent pastries

Craft coffee

Laptop OK

4.8

Wake Up Coffee Shop

1202 Kings Hwy, Brooklyn, NY 11229, USA

Excellent pastries

Craft coffee Open late

Laptop OKUntil 9pm

4.6

Ristretto Cafe

3121 Ocean Ave 2nd Fl, Brooklyn, NY 11235, USA

Excellent pastries

Craft coffee Open late

Until 10pm

4.4

Orso Coffee

1745 Sheepshead Bay Rd, Brooklyn, NY 11235, USA

Craft coffee

Laptop OK

Keep exploring Sheepshead Bay coffee

All Sheepshead Bay coffee Craft coffee across Brooklyn All Brooklyn shops

Sheepshead Bay specialty coffee, frequently asked

What are the best specialty coffee shops in Sheepshead Bay?: IGAM COFFEE, Lusso Le Caffe, Shepherd's Cup are among the best specialty coffee shops in Sheepshead Bay, each serving specialty-grade beans. Compare ratings and hours above.
How many craft coffee shops are in Sheepshead Bay?: We track 6 craft coffee shops in Sheepshead Bay, Brooklyn, each with verified amenities and Google ratings. The full list is above.